August 12, 2022

OAN Forced to Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal in Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow

” OAN naturally loses its appeal in its libel claim against Rachel Maddow,” he composed in a Tuesday tweet. “Will end up paying much more of Maddows attorneys costs.”.

OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow

One American News (OAN) has dealt with another loss in their legal fight versus MSNBCs Rachel Maddow..
On Tuesday, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals supported a previous court judgment that identified Maddows statements relating to the reactionary, pro-Donald Trump network were not actionable.
OAN, owned by Herring Networks, first took legal action against Maddow for $10 million in 2019 after the anchor identified the network as “paid Russian propaganda.”.
The fit knocked her comments as “harmful and entirely false,” regardless of the reality that they were based upon a Daily Beast report that noted OAN employs press reporter Kristian Rouz, who also worked for Kremlin-owned media outlet Sputnik.
” We literally found out today that outlet the President is promoting shares personnel with the Kremlin,” Maddow said following news of the Beasts report, adding, “In this case, the most obsequiously pro-Trump right wing news outlet in America really actually is paid Russian propaganda. Their on-air U.S. politics press reporter is paid by the Russian federal government to produce propaganda for that federal government.”.
OAN kept, nevertheless, that the network “is entirely financed by the Herrings, an American family” and “has never been paid or received a penny from Russia or the Russian government,” validating their disparagement suit.
A federal judge dismissed the suit in May 2020, concluding that Maddows declaration was “an opinion that can not function as the basis for a disparagement claim.”.
” Plaintiff has actually not shown a probability of being successful on its disparagement claims, hence, the Court GRANTS Defendants Special Motion to Strike,” added Judge Allison Goddard. “Finally, due to the fact that the Court grants the Motion, Defendants may file a movement for attorneys fees and expenses.”.
Following through with judges grant, MSNBC and Maddow asked for that OAN pay $350,000 in legal charges. In February, the court completely dismissed the case and granted the accuseds $247,667.50.
Despite the judgment, OAN president Charles Herring was “highly confident” that the network would “receive a beneficial and simply ruling in the United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.”.
Well, Herrings forecast was off the mark, as– in a 3-0 choice– the 9th Circuit preserved that Maddows declaration “was well within the bounds of what certified as protected speech under the First Amendment.”.
” The challenged declaration was an obvious exaggeration, cushioned within an indisputable news story,” said Judge Milan D. Smith Jr., adding, “The declaration could not reasonably be understood to suggest an assertion of unbiased reality, and therefore, did not total up to disparagement.”.
MSNBC and Maddow likewise won on an anti-SLAPP movement, suggesting they are entitled to the court-approved $250,000 in legal costs.
According to First Amendment legal representative Adam Steinbaugh, OAN might wind up paying even more, as they dragged out the procedure with an appeal:.

OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow

OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow
OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow
OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow
OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow
OAN Forced To Pay MSNBC $250,000 After Losing Appeal In Defamation Suit Against Rachel Maddow